I had the very good fortune of hearing former City of Montreal Mayor Valerie Plante speak about her experiences in furthering environmental initiatives for the city that she led from 2017 to 2025.
Because the event was in Toronto, the topic of bike lanes arose (of course) and she had some excellent insights, within which I found an inherent tension.
She spoke of introducing bike lanes on rue St. Denis during her tenure. She emphasized different aspects that lead to the eventual implementation (and success!) of the initiative. She used the metaphor of winning over hearts and minds. We look at minds first.
Frame the Problem & Build Evidence
The discussions about right things and right reasons can quickly deteriorate, but Mme. Plante’s counsel was to find a central outcome that provides unity among conflicting interests. Safety provided that common ground with a focus on reducing collisions. Rather than narrow self-serving framing, the frame extended to the wider citizenry, not just to bikers. Collisions included those between cars, as well as those that involved pedestrians and cyclists. Fewer collisions on a well-trafficked urban street is a parade that many can join, be it for different reasons.
Many in the room nodded as she recounted using historical data as the baseline comparison to what they gathered during the “pilot” of the expanded bike lanes. This is the critical thinking playbook:
Identify a problem
Select your evaluation criteria
Adopt a potential solution
Evaluate using the agreed upon criteria
Now for the hearts…
Entrench the Approach
To paraphrase, this one is best summed up as, “Whatever you do, make it hard to undo.” With the St. Denis bike lanes this included large concrete holders for trees that would be costly to remove, as well as unpopular owing to the aesthetic contribution to the streetscape.
This is no longer the “head” approach: rational, logical and evidence based. We have to accept the limitations of reasoned dialogue when it comes to polarizing issues (e.g. bike lanes or any number of municipal issues). Everyone appreciates rigour and transparency, but people are suspect of having arguments framed in an opponent-serving manner such that the evidence will automatically tilt to their side. Under the guise of critical thinking, people can seek out the framing and evidence that supports what they already believe.
For our beliefs, there can be that righteous moment when we know what we are doing is the right thing, and we think that the best way to make the case is to make it the ONLY option. Soon the doubters will see (begrudgingly) that we were right all along!
So…
Jettison the cork so we have to drink the whole bottle.
Sever the anchoring ties on that gorge-spanning rope bridge so we cannot back track.
Scuttle the lifeboat so we no one can leave the island alone.
Closing thought
The tension between hearts and minds exists in communicating with others, but also within our own understanding. Not all the elements of risk are quantifiable, so at some point it is a question of belief. Curiosity goes a long way in making sure that we fully explore the problem and the options. Maybe reducing the options (and making “failure” not one of them) can play a part in moving things forward.